On the study, Intensive methane seep region on the outer East Siberian Arctic Shelf shows biomarker evidence for aerobic oxidation of methane

Summary

Researchers examined sediment cores from an active methane seep region on the outer East Siberian Arctic Shelf and found that anaerobic methane oxidation (the traditional methane removal mechanism in seep sediments) was largely absent or inactive in the study area. Instead, the presence of strongly carbon-13-depleted hop-17(21)-ene biomarkers throughout the sediments indicates that aerobic methane oxidation (occurring in the water column and surface sediments) is the dominant process removing methane in this shallow, oxygen-rich system. This finding suggests that aerobic microbial processes play a significant role in regulating methane emissions from Arctic subsea permafrost vents, which has important implications for understanding how much methane from this region actually reaches the atmosphere.

Highlights

Methane in the East Siberian Arctic Shelf: Sources, Dynamics, and Oxidation Processes

The waters surrounding the East Siberian Arctic Shelf (ESAS) contain remarkably high concentrations of methane in both dissolved and gaseous forms throughout the entire water column, a phenomenon that has been consistently documented in recent scientific literature. This extensive continental shelf system is distinctive for several reasons: it represents the largest and shallowest shelf sea environment on Earth, with an average water depth of only 50 meters. During the early Holocene epoch, as global sea levels rose following the last glacial period, this vast area of non-glaciated permafrost tundra that characterized northeastern Eurasia became submerged beneath seawater. This unique geological history has created an environment where the sediments beneath the ESAS contain an extraordinarily high proportion—estimated between 60 and 80 percent—of all subsea permafrost globally. In addition to this frozen ground, these sediments hold significant quantities of methane hydrate deposits near the surface and deeper reserves of thermogenic gas originating from ancient organic material.

The subsea permafrost layer presents a particularly acute vulnerability to thermal degradation, and this thawing process stands as a major contributor to the methane emissions observed throughout the region. Over the approximately 20,000 years since the last ice age, the subsea permafrost has experienced continuous warming from two directions: the overlying seawater above and the geothermal heat emanating from below, which is especially pronounced in this tectonically dynamic area. Recent scientific drilling programs have yielded surprising findings: the rate at which subsea permafrost is thawing currently exceeds the thawing rates observed in similar permafrost deposits on adjacent land areas. Specifically, the boundary between frozen and thawed material—known as the permafrost table—has been descending into the sediments at an average rate of approximately 14 centimeters per year over the past three decades. Computer models designed to project future changes suggest that this thawing process may accelerate as human-induced climate change continues to warm the Arctic. This potential acceleration would create additional pathways through which methane can escape from subsea reservoirs, combining with methane released from hydrate dissociation and thermogenic sources to produce the extensive methane discharge observed across the entire ESAS.

The magnitude of methane emissions from the ESAS is remarkable when considered in a global context. Current scientific estimates indicate that the methane flux from this single Arctic shelf system exceeds the total methane flux from all of the world’s ocean basins combined. Within this system, subsea permafrost functions in a dual capacity: it serves simultaneously as a source of methane being released to the water column and as a physical barrier preventing the escape of methane from deeper geological reserves. To accurately forecast future atmospheric methane concentrations and climate impacts, scientists must precisely determine the relative importance of three distinct methane sources: the thawing subsea permafrost, the shallow methane hydrate deposits, and the deeper thermogenic gas accumulations. Recent research in the neighboring Laptev Sea region has provided clues suggesting that thermogenic gas reaches the seabed through either focused flow pathways or by penetrating through fractures in the overlying subsea permafrost, yet uncertainty remains regarding how these source contributions vary across the broader ESAS.

A critical gap in scientific understanding concerns the effectiveness of microbial processes in destroying methane before it can escape into the atmosphere. Two primary microbial pathways remove methane from the marine environment: anaerobic methane oxidation occurs in the seafloor sediments, while aerobic methane oxidation takes place in the water column. Both processes theoretically should minimize the amount of methane reaching the atmosphere. However, the scientific literature contains relatively few detailed studies of these methane-consuming microbial processes specifically within the ESAS. Several factors may limit the efficiency of methane removal in this particular environment. The shallow water column means that methane has less time to be consumed before potentially reaching the surface, and the relatively cold temperatures further inhibit microbial activity. Laboratory incubation experiments have measured methane oxidation rates in ESAS water samples and found them to be quite low—less than 0.1 nanomoles per liter per day—and notably slower than oxidation rates observed at other methane seep sites in the Arctic. Scientists have hypothesized that these low rates reflect both the relatively modest methane concentrations in ESAS water and the comparatively small microbial populations available to perform the oxidation. Intriguingly, ancient records of methane oxidation have been preserved in the ESAS sediments in the form of distinctive mineral precipitates called authigenic carbonates and unusual enrichments of rare-earth elements. These geochemical signatures are thought to record episodes of methane oxidation that occurred during periods of methane hydrate breakdown in the early Holocene warming, suggesting that methane cycling in the ESAS has a complex history involving variable methane releases and fluctuating oxidation efficiency.

To reconstruct and understand past and present methane cycling processes, scientists employ organic molecules called lipid biomarkers that are produced by specific microbial groups. Traditionally, researchers have used these molecular tracers to identify microorganisms responsible for anaerobic methane oxidation, including sulfate-reducing bacteria and specialized methane-consuming archaea. Sulfate-reducing bacteria leave characteristic chemical signatures in the form of specific fatty acids, while methane-consuming archaea produce distinctive molecules built on isoprenoid structures, such as compounds with names like archaeol and crocetane. In contrast, the bacteria responsible for aerobic methane oxidation—primarily certain groups of proteobacteria—generate hopanoid compounds with specific structures, most notably a compound called hop-17(21)-ene. However, interpreting these biomarkers requires caution because several different types of microorganisms, not only those involved in methane oxidation, can synthesize similar compounds. To definitively identify methane-oxidizing microorganisms, scientists therefore measure the carbon-13 content of these biomarker molecules. Methane-oxidizing microbes preferentially incorporate carbon-12, leaving their biomarkers severely depleted in the heavier carbon-13 isotope—a depletion greater than 50 parts per thousand relative to standard reference materials. This isotopic signature proves that the biomarker originated from methane consumption. Nevertheless, recent discoveries have complicated this interpretation: certain bacteria that perform anaerobic ammonia oxidation also produce hopanoid biomarkers with extreme carbon-13 depletion that exceeds 70 parts per thousand, making it impossible to distinguish their biomarkers from those of methane-oxidizing bacteria without additional evidence. Consequently, modern studies of ancient methane cycling require a sophisticated approach integrating multiple different lipid biomarkers combined with detailed carbon isotope measurements.

The fundamental aim of the present research was to characterize the current state of methane oxidation in the ESAS, paying particular attention to how oxidation dynamics might vary in response to fluctuating methane supplies. The investigators focused their sampling on a known hotspot region in the outer ESAS and analyzed both chemical profiles from pore fluids—specifically tracking how methane and sulfate concentrations change with depth—as well as the characteristic biomarker molecules preserved in the sediments and their distinctive carbon isotope compositions. These integrated measurements would together reveal which microbial oxidation pathways are active and how effectively they are consuming the methane escaping from subsurface sources.

Related

Vast methane ‘plumes’ seen in Arctic ocean as sea ice retreats